At Sibley Insurance Agency, we believe insurance should work for you—not the other way around.
We are a fully licensed independent brokerage agency serving clients across Indiana and Michigan, built on a simple principle:
give people real options, real advice, and real protection.
Unlike captive agencies that represent a single company, we partner with a wide network of top-rated A and A+ carriers, allowing us to shop multiple companies on your behalf. That means you’re not locked into one option—you get the best coverage at the most competitive value for your situation.
A True One-Stop Insurance Agency
Whether you're protecting your home, your vehicles, or your business, we bring everything under one roof:
Personal Insurance
Auto Insurance (Standard & Non-Standard)
Homeowners Insurance
Renters & Condo Coverage
Umbrella Policies
We understand that every household is different. That’s why we compare multiple carriers to find the right fit—whether you qualify for preferred rates or need flexible solutions.
Commercial Insurance Solutions
From startups to established operations, we provide coverage designed to keep your business moving forward.
We specialize in:
Restaurants & Food Service
Retail Stores
Contractors & Construction
Trucking & Hauling Operations
Service-Based Businesses
With access to multiple commercial carriers, we can tailor policies that match your industry, risk level, and growth goals—without forcing you into a one-size-fits-all plan.
Why Clients Choose Sibley Insurance Agency
✔ Independent Brokerage Model
We work for you—not the insurance company.
✔ Multiple A-Rated Carriers
Stronger options. Better protection. Competitive pricing.
✔ Standard & Non-Standard Markets
We help where others say no.
✔ Personalized Service
You’re not a policy number—you’re a relationship.
✔ Long-Term Strategy
We don’t just write policies—we help you build protection that grows with you.
Built on Experience. Focused on the Future.
With decades of industry experience, we’ve seen what works—and what doesn’t. That’s why we built Sibley Insurance Agency to be different:
Transparent conversations
Straightforward recommendations
No pressure, just solutions
We combine modern tools, responsive service, and real-world insurance knowledge to create a better experience from start to finish.
Your Protection Starts Here
Whether you're looking for a better rate, stronger coverage, or a second opinion—we’re here to help.
At Sibley Insurance Agency, you’re not just getting a quote.
You’re gaining a partner committed to protecting what matters most.